News Forum Blogs Roster Players Schedule Depth chart Stats Videos Photos

"A steep price," one rival GM called it, but only in strict baseball terms. For the Red Sox, this deal goes far beyond baseball. Ramirez was a distraction, a drain on the franchise. His departure could give the team the same type of psychological lift that the trade of Nomar Garciaparra did for the 2004 club that won the World Series.

Bay is not Ramirez, not even close — that is, when Ramirez is trying. But Ramirez, at times, had stopped trying, stopped even playing, perhaps because his right knee was indeed injured. Without him, the Red Sox's offense still will be one of the league's best. Defensively, Bay will need to learn how to play the Green Monster, but c'mon, he's only replacing Manny.

A few days ago, I wrote that a Ramirez blockbuster was just the type of mountain that Red Sox GM Theo Epstein loves to climb. He essentially climbed it twice, first coming close on a three-way with the Marlins, then completing it with the Dodgers. Sure, the Red Sox's resources give Epstein an immense advantage. But he did what he had to do.

The Pirates, too, made the right call, trading Bay when his value was at its peak, rather than last offseason, after it had plummeted. True, none of the players they acquired looks like a future star. But in this trade and the much-maligned Xavier Nady/Damaso Marte deal, the Pirates added eight young players. Some are bound to succeed.

LaRoche should be a solid major-league third baseman. Moss, in the Red Sox's own opinion, could start for many clubs. Hansen hasn't shown he can throw consistent strikes, but he might thrive outside of Boston, where he faced the pressure of being a former No. 1 pick. Morris already has had his Tommy John surgery — a good thing these days — and joins former Yankees Ross Ohlendorf and Daniel McCutchen as potential members of the Pirates' future rotation.

Pirates president Frank Coonelly and GM Neal Huntington already have taken a markedly different approach than their predecessors, demonstrating a willingness to make tough decisions and big deals. Whether Huntington chose the right players remains to be seen, but at least the Pirates were in there swinging with the Yankees and Red Sox.

The deadline is not for the faint of heart, and three-way negotiations only add to the stress. Epstein, Colletti and Huntington can breathe easier, at least for the moment.

Everybody wins.


Author:Fox Sports
Author's Website:http://www.foxsports.com
Added: August 1, 2008

Milwaukee Brewers News

News » Take your pick: Manny deal produced winners all around


Take your pick: Manny deal produced winners all around


Take your pick: Manny deal produced winners all around
Everybody wins.

The Red Sox, by purging Manny Ramirez and acquiring Jason Bay as a legitimate right-handed hitting replacement.

MLB roundup


Thursday's action


  • Edmonds helps Cubs complete sweep
  • Sizemore helps Tribe pound out a win
  • Werth's HR helps Phils double up Nats
  • M's hang on to down Rangers
  • Cards blow chance against Braves
  • Teix debuts as Halos rout Yanks
  • Marlins' Sanchez bafflles Rockies
  • Webb leads D-backs over Dodgers

More on MLB:


  • Perry: Deadline winners and losers
  • Rosenthal: Dodgers finally pulled it off
  • Rosenthal: Sox ship Manny to Dodgers
  • Rosenthal: Junior OKs trade to ChiSox

Photo gallery:


  • Trade deadline drama

  • 2008 Hall of Fame class

  • Baseball's best mustaches

Milestone tracker:


    Follow Randy Johnson's quest for 300 wins and Gary Sheffield's chase for 500 HR in the AT&T Milestone Tracker.

The Pirates, by obtaining four young players for Bay, three of whom will contribute immediately, the fourth of whom could develop into a mid-rotation starter.

And finally, the Dodgers. Yes, the Dodgers. For once, the Dodgers were the biggest winners of all.

Commissioner Bud Selig might want to ask why one of the game's jewel franchises is unable to add payroll at the non-waiver deadline.

The Dodgers sure will look funny with outfielders Andruw Jones and Juan Pierre sitting on the bench, their combined salaries higher than the Marlins' entire payroll.

But at least general manager Ned Colletti turned it loose, acquiring Ramirez for a two-month burst in which everyone's favorite 8-year-old should be more motivated than at any point in his career.

Ramirez deserves scorn for pushing and limping and bad-mouthing his way out of Boston, for viewing his $20 million club option as a form of incarceration and not part of a signed contract.

Jeff Kent will love him, don't you think?

Of course, the Dodgers will overlook all of Manny's faults once he starts mashing, just as the Red Sox tolerated him when he formed the game's most dynamic 3-4 combination with David Ortiz.

For the Dodgers, locked in a tight race with the Diamondbacks in the mediocre NL West, there was everything to gain and little to lose.

The Dodgers weren't all that enamored of third baseman Andy LaRoche; otherwise, they would have passed on trading for Casey Blake. Class A right-hander Bryan Morris, the other player they sent to the Pirates, is at least two years away.

Meaningful losses, but replaceable with the two premium draft picks the Dodgers will receive if they decline to re-sign Ramirez as a free agent. Combine that with the payment they will receive from the Red Sox to cover the rest of Ramirez's salary, and they're getting a future Hall of Famer almost for free.

For months, weeks, years, the Dodgers have been a bane to rival clubs, exasperating them with their inscrutable front-office dynamics, their shifting trade offers, their inability to close deals.

An hour before Thursday's blockbuster, I sent a text message to an executive with one of the teams involved in the three-way discussions and asked the chances of the Dodgers landing Ramirez.

His response: "You know that process ..." And I could almost hear his sigh come through my cell phone.

Earlier this month, the Dodgers had a chance to land left-hander CC Sabathia, Blake and infielder Jamey Carroll from the Indians, but owner Frank McCourt rejected the deal because it would have added more than $7 million in payroll, according to major-league sources.

Well, give Colletti credit — he kept plugging. As it turns out, the Dodgers were better off passing on CC; Ramirez will make a greater impact on their offense than even Sabathia would have made on their rotation.

Never mind that the deal only happened because the Red Sox were utterly desperate to move Ramirez, and because the Marlins ultimately declined to pay the necessary price for him.

No one cares at the end.

Consider the Red Sox, who effectively traded two months of Ramirez, the approximately $7 million remaining on his contract, outfielder Brandon Moss and reliever Craig Hansen for a year plus two months of Bay.

MLB trade deadline

Manny Ramirez
Latest news:
  • Manny to Dodgers in blockbuster
  • Reds trade Griffey to White Sox
  • Tigers send Pudge to Yankees
  • Astros nab Hawkins from Yanks


Analysis:
  • Rosenthal: Dodgers finally pull one off
  • Perry: Deadline winners and losers
  • Perry: Tigers not surrendering


More on the trades:
  • VIDEO: Torre ready for Manny
  • VIDEO: Dodgers owner talks Manny
  • VIDEO: Rosenthal on Teixeira deal
la
Milwaukee Brewers Photos
All the latest Milwaukee Brewers Photos Store photographs. Major League Baseball MLB.
The most recent photo
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Add to Windows Live

Copyright © Brewershome.com, Inc. All rights reserved 2008.